STUDYING OF THE HISTORICAL MEMORY PROBLEM IN KAZAKHSTAN: A HISTORIOGRAPHICAL REVIEW
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.51943/2710-3994_2023_36_4_725-743Ключевые слова:
Память, историческая память, историография, казахстанская историография, место памятиАннотация
Введение. В последние годы казахстанские ученые стали проявлять научный интерес к феномену исторической памяти. В частности, проблема исторической памяти становится предметом и объектом изучения историков, философов, социологов, культурологов и других специалистов гуманитарной сферы. В статье изучены труды казахстанских исследователей, рассматривавших различные аспекты проблемы исторической памяти. Описаны основные направления изучения исторической памяти в казахстанской науке. Цель и задачи исследования – проведение анализа научных трудов по проблеме исторической памяти в отечественной историографии и определение конкретных тематических групп в этих публикациях и постановка вопросов, требующих дальнейшего изучения; определение основных аспектов исторической памяти, рассматриваемых в этих работах; определение значимости всестороннего и тщательного изучения проблемы исторической памяти в Казахстане. Результаты. Большую часть работ по исследуемой теме составляют научные статьи, основная часть которых опубликована в материалах международных, республиканских научно-практических конференций, в научных журналах. Существует очень мало специальных исследований и научных монографий, посвященных проблеме исторической памяти. Большая часть работ казахстанских исследователей по исторической памяти были опубликованы за последние 7–8 лет. Отдельные ученые выполняли исследовательские проекты на темы, связанные с исторической памятью, и публиковали статьи в рамках проекта. Выводы. В результате историографического обзора выявлены хорошо изученные или недостаточно изученные аспекты феномена исторической памяти в казахстанской историографии. Анализируя отечественные исследования, посвященные проблеме исторической памяти, авторы приходят к выводу, что многие аспекты данной проблемы еще требуют тщательного и систематического изучения.
Скачивания
Библиографические ссылки
Abil, Kuzembayuly, 2021 — Abil E.A., Kuzembayuly A. “Materialy po kirgizskomu zemlepol'zovaniju” kak istochnik po izucheniju istoricheskoj pamyati kazahov Severnogo Kazahstana [“Materials on the Kirghiz land use” as a source for studying the historical memory of the Kazakhs of Northern Kazakhstan]. Bylye Gody. 2021. No. 16(3). Pp. 1463–1472. (In Russ.)
Absadikov, Minnegulov, 2016 — Absadikov A.A., Minnegulov H.Ju. Halyqtyn tarihi zhady zhane fol'klor [People's historical memory and folklore]. “Baitursynov readings – 2016”. Part 2. “Science, production, business: contemporary state and ways of innovative development of the country”. Kostanay: A. Baitursynov KSU, 2016. Pp. 223–225. (In Kaz.)
Abylkhozhin, Krupko, 2020 — Abylkhozhin Zh.B., Krupko I.V. Istoricheskij kontekst problem modernizacii obshhestvennogo soznanija i kul'turnoj pamyati kazahstanskogo sociuma [Historical context of the problems of (3) modernisation of public consciousness and cultural memory of Kazakh society]. Bulletin of IICAS. Publication of the International Institute for Central Asian Studies. 2020. Vol. 30. Pp. 7–18. (In Russ.) Aitylgan tarikh, 2015 — Aitylgan tarikh. Oqu quraly [Aitylgan tarikh. Educational tool]. Koygeldiev M.K., Nurtazina N.D., et al. Almaty: “Dastur”publishing house, 2015. 240 p. (In Kaz.)
Akylbaeva, 2019 — Akylbaeva I.M. Istoricheskaja pamyat' i pogruzhenie molodezhi v nacional'nye vizual'nye kody [Historical memory and the immersion of youth in the national visual codes]. “History of the Great Steppe: from the origins to the present”: Materials of the International Eurasian Forum. Nur-Sultan: L.N. Gumiyov ENU, 2019. 354 p. (In Russ.)
Alіmgazinov, Chilikova, 2017 — Alіmgazinov Q., Chilikova E. Tarihi zhady kenіstіgіndegі Alash qozgalysy (Qazaqstan Respublikasy Prezidentі Arhivіnіn materialdaryna derektanulyq zhane arheografijalyq sholu) [Alash movement in the space of historical memory (source and archeographic review of the materials of the Archive of the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan)]. Society&Time. Scientific and expert Journal. 2017. No. 1(53). Pp. 55–71. (In Kaz.)
Alimova, 2015 — Alimova S.B.“Narod v potoke istorii”: o roli istoricheskogo nasledija v formirovanii kazahstanskoj identichnosti [“People in the stream of history”:the role of historical heritage in the formation of Kazakh identity]. Materials of the International scientific and practical conference. Vol. 1. Karaganda: E.A. Buketov KSU, 2015. Pp. 349–352. (In Russ.)
Alpysbes, 1999 — Alpysbes M.A. Istorija Kazahstana v kazahskom shezhire (mesto shezhire v izuchenii istorii) [The history of Kazakhstan in Kazakh shezhire (place of shegyre in learning of history)]: autoref. ...: 07.00.02. Karaganda, 1999. 30 p. (In Russ.)
Alpysbes, 2013 — Alpysbes M.A. Qazaq shezhіresі: tarihnamalyq-derektanulyq zertteu: monografija. [Kazakh shezhire: historiographical and source study research: monograph]. Astana: “BG-Print” IE, 2013. 380 p. (In Kaz.)
Amanzholova, 2012 – Amanzholova D.A. Istoricheskaja pamyat' postsovetskogo obshhestva i kul'tura molodezhi: problemy preemstvennosti i vyzovy modernizacii [Historical memory of the post-Soviet society and youth culture: problems of succession and challenges of modernization]. History of Kazakhstan: teaching in school. 2012. No. 2. Pp. 2–4. (In Russ.)
Amanzholova, 2016 – Amanzholova D.A. Istoricheskaja pamyat' kak politicheskij resurs vo vzaimodejstvii postsovetskih stran [Historical memory as a political resource in the interaction of post-Soviet countries]. Human capital. 2016. No. 4(88). Pp. 83–85. (In Russ.)
Amanzholova, 2019 – Amanzholova D.A. Sociokul'turnye faktory Pobedy SSSR v Velikoj Otechestvennoj vojne i problemy formirovanija istoricheskoj pamyati molodezhi [Sociocultural factors of the Victory of the USSR in the Great Patriotic War and problems of the formation of historical memory of the youth]. Kazakhs in the Eurasian space: history, culture and sociocultural processes: collection of scientific works. Omsk: OSU, 2019. Pp. 19–24. (In Russ.)
Amanzholova, 2020 – Amanzholova D.A. Pamyat' o Velikoj Otechestvennoj vojne v Kazahstane – osobennosti interpretacii [Memory of the Great Patriotic War in Kazakhstan – special interpretation]. The Great Patriotic War in the historical memory of the nation: study, interpretation, lessons of the past: collection of materials of the All-Russian scientific and practical conference with international participation Novosibirsk: Parallel, 2020. Pp. 8–19. (In Russ.)
Artykbaev, 2012 — Artykbaev J.A. Qazaqtyn auyzsha dasturі: ugym zhane tapsіrleu maselelerі [Kazakh oral tradition: concepts and interpretation problems]. Akseleu Seydimbek: scientific heritage and independence (problems of oral history). Proceedings of the international scientific and theoretical conference. Astana: L.N. Gumilyov ENU, 2012. Pp. 19–28. (In Kaz.)
Assman, 2004 — Assman Ja. Kul'turnaja pamyat': Pis'mo, pamyat' o proshlom i politicheskaja identichnost' v vysokih kul'turah drevnosti [Cultural memory: Writing, memory of the past and political identity in the high cultures of antiquity]. Moscow: Jazyki slavjanskoj kul'tury, 2004. 368 p. (In Russ.)
Connerton, 1989 – Connerton P. How Societies Remember. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1989. 121 p. (In Eng.)
Connerton, 2008 – Connerton P. Seven types of forgetting. Memory Studies, 2008. No. 1. Pp. 59–71. (In Eng.) Connerton,2009 – Connerton P.How Modernity Forgets. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2009. 149 p.(In Eng.) (3)
Ensenov, 2012 — Ensenov K.A.Qazaq halqynyn tarihi zhady zhane auyzsha tarih ajtu dasturі [Historical memory of the Kazakh people and tradition of telling oral history] //Akseleu Seydimbek: scientific heritage and independence (problems of oral history). Proceedings of the international scientific and theoretical conference. Astana: L.N. Gumilyov ENU, 2012. Pp. 98–100. (In Kaz.)
Ermagambetova, Orazbaeva, 2022 — Ermagambetova K.S., Orazbaeva D.E.Shygys Qazaqstan onіrіnde batyrlardy memorialdau urdіsі: madeni antropologijalyq taldau [The process of commemorating heroes in the region East Kazakhstan: cultural anthropological analysis]. Keruen. 2022. No. 1. Vol. 74. Pp. 316–333. (In Kaz.)
Erofeeva, 2016 — Erofeeva I.V.Znakovyj personazh kazahskih predanij Alasha-han: istoricheskaja lichnost' i mif [Iconic character of Kazakh legends Alasha Khan: historical personality and myth]. Turkological Collection Moscow: Science – Eastern Literature, 1970. 2013–2014 / 2016. Pp. 256–292. (In Russ.)
Erofeeva, 2021 — Erofeeva I.V.“Dobryj” ili “svjatoj” Dzhanibek-han (1342–1357) v ustnoj istoricheskoj pamyati kochevnikov-kazahov [“Good” or "holy" Janibek Khan (1342–1357) in the oral historical memory of the nomadic Kazakhs]. Golden Horde Review. 2021. Vol. 9. No. 1. Pp. 149–165. (In Russ.)
Eshpanova, 2016 — Eshpanova D.D.Rol' istoricheskoj pamyati v sociokul'turnom razvitii jetnosov Kazahstana [The role of historical memory in the socio-cultural development of ethnos of Kazakhstan]. Historical memory as a source of construction of Kazakh. Proceedings of the scientific and practice conference Almaty: IFPR CS MES RK, 2016. Pp. 71–80. (In Russ.)
Etkind, 2004 – Etkind A.Hard and Soft in Cultural Memory: Political Mourning in Russia and Germany. Grey Room (MIT Press). Special Issue: Memory/History/Democracy. 2004. Vol. 16. Pp. 36–59. (In Eng.)
Etkind, 2016 – Etkind A. Krivoe gore. Pamyat o nepogrebyennykh [Warped Mourning: Stories of the Undead in the Land of the Unburied]. Moscow: Novoye literaturnoe obozrenie, 2016. 328 p. (In Russ.)
Galiyev, 2016 — Galiyev A.A. Otrazhenie sovetskoj istorii v politike pamyati sovremennogo Kazahstana [Reflection of Soviet history in the politics of memory of modern Kazakhstan]. World of Great Altai. 2016. No. 2(3.1) Pp. 430–440. (In Russ.)
Galiyev, 2018a — Galiyev A.A. Istorija i travmy proshlogo v politike pamyati gosudarstv Central'noj Azii [History and trauma of the past in the politics of memory of the state of Central Asia]. Historical memory: traumas of the past, contradictions of the present,perspectives of the future. A collection of articles on the results of the All-Russian scientific conference. Saratov: IC “Nauka”, 2018. Pp. 29–34. (In Russ.)
Galiyev, 2018b — Galiyev A.A. Politika pamyati v stranah Central'noy Azii i problemy naciestroitel'stva [The politics of memory in the countries of Central Asia and the problems of nation-building]. Bulletin of Zh. Balasagyn Kyrgyz National University. 2018. No. 2(94). Pp. 89–93. (In Russ.)
Galiyev, Myrzakhmetova, 2019 — Galiyev A.A., Myrzakhmetova A.Zh. (2019). Velikaja Otechestvennaja vojna v politike pamyati v Rossijskoj Federacii i Respublike Kazahstan [The Great Patriotic War in the politics of memory in the Russian Federation and the Republic of Kazakhstan]. Bulletin of the Karaganda University. History. Philosophy series. 2019. Vol. 94. No. 2. Pp. 24–30. (In Russ.)
Grozin, 2014 – Grozin A.V. Golod 1932–1933 godov i politika pamyati v respublike Kazahstan [Famine of 1932–1933 and political memory in the Republic of Kazakhstan]. Moscow: Institute of Oriental Studies RAS, 2014. 178 p. (In Russ.)
Halbwachs, 2007 — Halbwachs M. Social'nye ramki pamyati [Social memory frames]. Moscow: Novoe izdatelstvo, 2007. 348 p. (In Russ.) Historical memory, 2016 — Historical memory as a source of construction of Kazakh identity. Proceedings of science and practice conference. Almaty: IFPR CS MES RK, 2016. 140 p. (In Russ.)
Irmukhanov, 2007 —Irmukhanov B.B. O nauchnoj preemstvennosti pri issledovanii problem istorii Kazahstana [Scientific continuity in the study of problems of the history of Kazakhstan].The phenomenon of nomadism in the history of Eurasia. Nomadism and development of the state: Proceedings of the International Scientific Conference. Almaty: Dyke-Press, 2007. Pp. 133–144. (In Russ.)
Kadyrzhanov, 2016 — Kadyrzhanov R.K. Istoricheskaja pamyat' i nacional'noe stroitel'stvo v Kazahstane [Historical memory and national construction in Kazakhstan]. Historical memory as a source of construction of Kazakh identity. Proceedings of the science and practice conference. Almaty: IFPR CS MES RK, 2016. Pp. 81–87. (In Russ.)
Kalenova, Zhalelova, 2022 — Kalenova T.S., Zhalelova G.M. Nacional'nye cennosti i istoricheskaja pamyat' kazahskogo naroda [National values and historical memory of the Kazakh people]. Political space and social time: The power of symbols and the memory of generations. Collection of scientific papers of the XXVIII International (3) Kharaksky Forum. Simferopol: IT "ARIAL", 2022. Pp. 143–147. (In Russ.)
Koygeldiev, 2013 — Koygeldiev M.K. Memlekettіlіgіn quryp zhatqan ulttyn tarihshysy kuresker boluy kerek! [The historian of the nation that is building its state should be a fighter!]. Mirror of Alash. No. 95(1006). 7.06.2013. (In Kaz.)
Krupko, 2020 — Krupko I.V. Fol'klornye sjuzhety kazahstanskoj istoriografii: mezhdu pojetikoj i politikoj pamyati [Folkloric subjects of Kazakh historiography: between poetic and political memory] [Electronic resource]. Working paper No. 34: “Sujets folkloriques de l’historiographie kazakhe: entre poétique et politique de la mémoire” PAR IFEAC 04/08/2020 URL: https://ifeac.hypotheses.org/6885 (access date: 12.06.2023). (In Russ.)
Krupko, 2022 —Krupko I.V. Otyrar kіtaphanasynyn bejne zhane narrativ semiozisі: zhogalgan agartushylyqty іzdestіru barysynda [Semiosis of the image and narrative of the Otrar library: in search of the lost enlightenment] [electronic resource]. “edu.e-history.kz” electronic scientific journal. 2022. No. 9(3). Pp. 112–125. URL: https://doi.org/10.51943/2710-3994_2022_31_3_112-125 (access date: 10.06.2023). (In Kaz.)
Kudaybergenova, 2020 — Kudaybergenova A.A. Kommemoracija lichnosti Mustafy Shokaja: pamyatniki, kinematograf [Commemoration personality Mustafy Shokai: monument, cinematographer]. Bulletin of L.N. Gumilyov ENU. Historical Sciences. Philosophy. Religion series. 2020. No. 1(130). Pp. 107–118. (In Russ.)
Kundakbayeva, 2011 – Kundakbayeva Zh. History textbooks and their role in the construction of memory and identity of the young generation in Kazakhstan. Materials of the international scientific conference "Dulatovsky readings: historical science and teaching of history in modern Kazakhstan, Russia and the states of Central Asia" Almaty, 2011. Pp. 50–52. (In Russ.)
Kundakbayeva, 2013 — Kundakbayeva Zh. V poiskah istoricheskogo narrativa Kazahstana: “dialog pamyati” ili “nacional'naja pamyat'” [In search of the historical narrative of Kazakhstan: "dialog memory" or "national memory"] [electronic resource]. Qazaqstan Tarihy portal. 10.08.2013. URL: https://e-history.kz/ru/ seo-materials/show/29146 (access date: 16.05.2023). (In Russ.)
Kundakbayeva, Kassymova, 2016 – Kundakbayeva Zh., Kassymova D. Remembering and forgetting: the state policy of memorializing Stalin's repression in post-Soviet Kazakhstan. Nationalities Papers. 2016. Vol. 44. Issue 4. Pp. 611–627. (In Eng.)
Kurmanalina, 2017a — Kurmanalina N.N. XVІІІ gasyrdagy qazaq jetnosy tarihi zhadynyn derektіk erekshelіkterі [Documentary features of the historical memory of the Kazakh ethnos in the 18th century]. Actual scientific research in the modern world. 2017. No. 9–4 (29). Pp. 11–16. (In Kaz.)
Kurmanalina, 2017b — Kurmanalina N.N.XІX gasyr oqigalary qazaq halqynyn tarihi zhadynda [The events of the 19th century are in the historical memory of the Kazakh people]. Actual scientific researches in the modern world. 2017. No. 9-4(29). Pp. 17–21. (In Kaz.)
Kuzembayuly et al., 2022 — Kuzembayuly A., Abil' E.A., Alibek T. Sibirskij ulus i kazahi: problemy jetnicheskoj preemstvennosti i istoricheskoj pamyati [Siberian ulus and Kazakhs: problems of ethnic succession and historical memory]. Kostanay, 2022. 256 p. (In Russ.)
Leontieva, 2015 — Leontieva O.B.“Memorial'nyj povorot” v sovremennoj Rossijskoj istoricheskoj nauke [“Memorial turn” in the contemporary Russian historical science] [electronic resource]. Dialogue with time. 2015. Vol. 50. Pp. 59–96. URL: https://roii.ru/r/1/50.3 (access date: 10.06.2023). (In Russ.)
Medeuova, 2016 — Medeuova K.A.K voprosu o tipologii praktik pamyati v Kazahstane [The question of typology of practical memory in Kazakhstan]. World of Great Altai. 2016. No. 2(3.1). Pp. 450–458. (In Russ.)
Medeuova, 2020 — Medeuova K.A. Zatjanuvshajasja «sovetskost'» i transformacii kollektivnoj pamyati: sovetskie i postsovetskie memorial'nye kompleksy v Kazahstane [Lingering "Sovietness" and transformation of collective memory: Soviet and post-Soviet memorial complexes in Kazakhstan]. New Literary Review. 2020. No. 1. Pp. 256–274. (In Russ.)
Medeuova, Sandybayeva, 2018 — Medeuova K.A., Sandybayeva U.M. Sakral'naja geografija v Kazahstane: kommemorativnaja politika gosudarstva i lokal'nye praktiki v publichnyh prostranstvah [Sacred geography in Kazakhstan: state commemorative policy and local practices in public spaces]. World of Great Altai. 2018. No. 4(3). Pp. 438–447. (In Russ.)
Medeuova et al., 2022 — Medeuova K., Sandybaeva U., Bakytova L. Kosmicheskie mesta pamyati v Kazahstane [Space places of memory in Kazakhstan]. Creativity and modernity. 2022. No. 1(16). Pp. 64–67. (In Russ.)
Myrzataeva, 2019 — Myrzataeva Z.B. Tyl deportacijaga ushyragan poljak azamattarynyn estelіkterіnde (Turkіstan, Sozaq audandary materialdarynyn negіzіmen) 1941–1945 zhzh. [In the memoirs of Polish citizens who (3) were deported to the rear (on the basis of materials from Turkestan, Sozak districts) 1941–1945]. Bulletin of the Abai Kazakh National Pedagogical University. Historical and Socio-Political Sciences series. 2019. No. 3(62). Pp. 24–30. (In Kaz.)
Nasimov, 2019 — Nasimov M. Tarihi zhadyny qalyptastyrudyn ozektі maselelerі [Actual problems of historical memory formation]. Human world: philosophical and social humanitarian journal. 2017. No. 2(72). Pp. 152–164. (In Kaz.)
Naurzbaeva, 2019 — Naurzbaeva Z. Rodoslovnye “shezhіre” kak forma kollektivnoj pamyati [Genealogical “shezhire” as a form of collective memory] [electronic resource]. otuken.kz Site about Kazakh culture, music and mythology. 28.07.2019. URL: https://otuken.kz/shezhire/ (access date: 23.06.2023). (In Russ.)
Nogaybayeva, Toksanbaev, 2019 — Nogaybayeva M.S., Toksanbaev A.K. Koshpelі қogamdagy bileushі bejnesіnіn anyz-ertegіlerdegі korіnіsі [The image of the governor in tales and legends in the nomadic society]. [electronic resource].“edu.e-history.kz” electronic scientific journal. 2019. No. 3(19). URL: https://edu.ehistory.kz/index.php/history/article/view/81/34 (access date: 20.04.2023). (In Kaz.)
Nora, 1999 — Nora P. Francija-pamyat' [France-memory].P. Nora, M. Ozuf, J. de Puymege, M. Vinok. Saint Petersburg: Saint Petersburg University Publishing House, 1999. 328 p. (In Russ.)
Praktiki, 2017 — Praktiki i mesta pamyati v Kazahstane [Practices and places of memory in Kazakhstan].
Medeuova K.A., Sandybaeva U.M., Naurzbaeva Z. et al. Astana: L.N. Gumilyov ENU, 2017. 350 p. (In Russ.)
Rahimbekova, 2019 — Rahimbekova A.K. Istoricheskaja pamyat' i stepnaja ustnaja istoriologija [Historical memory and steppe oral historiology]. Historical and pedagogical readings. 2019. No. 23. Pp. 175–180. (In Russ.)
Repina, 2016 — Repina L.P. Sobytija i obrazy proshlogo v istoricheskoj i kul'turnoj pamyati [Events and images of the past in historical and cultural memory]. The New Past. 2016. No. 1. Pp. 82–99. (In Russ.)
Rostovtcev, Sosnitskiy, 2014 — Rostovtcev E.A., Sosnitskiy D.A. Napravlenija issledovanij istoricheskoj pamyati v Rossii [Directions of historical research in Russia]. Saint Petersburg University Bulletin. 2014. Ser. 2, Vol. 2. Pp. 106–126. (In Russ.)
Sagatova, Tuyakova, 2021 — Sagatova A.S., Tuyakova N.B. Historical memory in the era of independence. Bulletin of Karaganda University. History. Philosophy series. 2021. No. 4(104). Pp. 196–202. (In Eng.)
Saktaganova, 2019 — Saktaganova Z.G. Batyr Rajymbek Alban: chto nam o nem izvestno? [Rayymbek Alban Batyr: what do we know about him?]. World of Great Altay. 2019. No. 5(4). Pp. 479–490. (In Russ.)
Sandybayeva, 2020 — Sandybayeva U.M.Politika pamyati v postsovetskij period: memorial'nyj landshaft pamyati o Grazhdanskoj vojne v Kazahstane [The Politics of memory in the post-Soviet Period: the memorial landscape of the memory of the Civil War in Kazakhstan]. E-Scio. 2020. No. 9(48). Pp. 358–373. (In Russ.)
Sandybayeva, Alzhanova, 2019 — Sandybayeva U.M., Alzhanova G.M.“Mesta pamyati” kak kul'turnyj kapital regiona: sakral'nyj potencial Bajanaula "Memory place" as the cultural capital of the region: the sacred potential of Bayanaul]. World of Great Altay. 2019. No. 5(4). Pp. 629–649. (In Russ.)
Savelyeva, Poletaev, 2008 — Savelyeva I.M., Poletaev A.V. Obydennye predstavlenija o proshlom: teoreticheskie podhody [Common views of the past: theoretical approaches]. Dialogues with time: memory of the past in the context of history. Moscow, 2008. Pp. 50–76. (In Russ.)
Smagambet, 2014 — Smagambet B.Zh. Kоne turkі adebi muralary zhane Ortalyq Azija halyqtarynyn aleumettіk zhady [Ancient Turkic literary heritage and the social memory of the peoples of Central Asia]. National strategies for the development of Turkic-speaking countries. Proceedings of the V Congress of Sociologists of Turkic-speaking countries Almaty, 2014. Pp. 511–518. (In Kaz.)
Sultangazy, Mukataeva, 2020 — Sultangazy G.J., Mukataeva L.K. Istoricheskaja pamyat' v uslovijah sovremennogo Kazahstana: poiski geroev i smyslov [Historical memory in the conditions of modern Kazakhstan: search for heroes and meanings]. [Electronic resource].“edu.e-history.kz” electronic scientific journal. 2020. No. 2(22). URL: https://edu.e-history.kz/index.php/history/article/download/413/723 (access date: 25.05.2021). (In Russ.)
Suraganova, Sarsembina, 2021 — Suraganova Z.K., Sarsembina K.K. Kumysnye prazdniki, ritualy i ceremonii v kontekste pomnjashhej kul'tury Velikoj stepi [Kumis holidays, rituals and ceremonies in the context of the commemorative culture of the Great Steppe] [Electronic resource]. Historical Ethnology. 2021. Vol. 6. No. 2. Pp. 257–270. URL: https://doi.org/10.22378/he.2021-6-2. (access date: 25.05.2021). (In Russ.)
Tolgambaeva, 2019 — Tolgambaeva D.T. Pamyat' o Velikoj otechestvennoj vojne: praktiki memorializacii v sovremennom Kazahstane [Memory of the Great Patriotic War: the practice of memorialization in modern Kazakhstan]. Historical Memory of Belarus as a factor in the consolidation of society: materials of the International (3) science and practice conference. Minsk: LLC SUGART, 2019. Pp. 179–181. (In Russ.)
Tuleuova et al., 2019 — Tuleuova B.T., Gorovoj V.V., Shotbakova L.K. Rol' instituta sem'i v formirovanii istoricheskogo znanija molodogo pokolenija [The role of the family institution in the formation of historical knowledge of the young generation]. Bulletin of the Karaganda University. History. Philosophy series. 2019. Vol. 93. No. 1. Pp. 75–81. (In Russ.)
Turlybekova, 2019 — Turlybekova A.M. Interpretacija ponjatij istoricheskogo soznanija i istoricheskoj pamyati v nauchnoj literature [Interpretation of concepts of historical consciousness and historical memory in scientific literature]. Bulletin of Abai Kazakh National Pedagogical University. Series “Historical and sociopolitical sciences”. No. 3(62), 2019. Pp. 305–309. (In Russ.)
Tursynbaeva, 2018 — Tursynbaeva A.O. Sanany zhangyrtudagy tarihi zhadynyn rolі [The role of historical memory in the renewal of consciousness]. Actual problems of world philosophy, human development, its consciousness and morality: Proceedings of the International scientific-theoretical conference Astana, 2018. Pp. 173–176. (In Kaz.)
Yates, 1997 — Yates F. Iskusstvo pamyati [The Art of Memory]. Saint Petersburg: Universitetskaya kniga, 1997. 480 p. (In Russ.)
Zhanbosinova, 2022 — Zhanbosinova A.S. Istoricheskaja pamyat' o Velikoj Otechestvennoj vojne v prostranstve Kazahstana [Historical Memory of the Great Patriotic War in the space of Kazakhstan]. Historical courier, 2022. No. 1(21). Pp. 133–144. (In Russ.)
Zhanbosinova, Erdembekov, 2017 — Zhanbosinova A.S., Erdembekov B.A. Koncepty kul'turnoj pamyati i social'nye praktiki v Kazahstane [Concepts of cultural memory and social practices in Kazakhstan]. Bulletin of Novosibirsk State University. History, Philology series. 2017. Vol. 16. No. 1. Pp. 29–39. (In Russ.) Zhivaya pamyat, 2019 — Zhivaya pamyat. Stalinizm v Kazahstane – Proshloe, Pamyat', Preodolenie [Living Memory. Stalinism in Kazakhstan – Past, Memory, Overcoming]. Almaty: Dyke-Press, 2019. 272 p. (In Russ.) 121 p. 149 p.
Загрузки
Опубликован
Как цитировать
Выпуск
Раздел
Лицензия
Copyright (c) 2023 Электронный научный журнал «edu.e-history.kz»

Это произведение доступно по лицензии Creative Commons «Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives» («Атрибуция — Некоммерческое использование — Без производных произведений») 4.0 Всемирная.
- Аннотация 1761
- PDF (English) 780




